Goyshuso-sama Train Wreck?

It’s been suggested by folks who may have seen the raws that the ending of Goyshuso-sama Ninomiya-kun is going to a train wreck. I can’t say as I’m surprised by that at all; while I may have voted for “Who cares, I’m just watching Mayu,” (and I am, or was, until Red-eyed Reika returned), I definitely have not expected anything like a logical, well-planned ending since the head-fake around episode five. Nor was it high on my list of expectations prior to that, actually.

But the question I am considering is: “What kind of train wreck are we going to have?” Simply put, “train wreck” is one of those lovely ambiguous phrases that means different things to different people. As a result, they tend to get into arguments based on mutual misunderstandings, and being otaku, such disputes generally don’t end without the involvement of large mechas and the general destruction of Tokyo. Fortunately, orbital lasers are only involved in the worst cases.

To prevent such dire events, I have decided to step in and provide all potentially warring parties with some useful definitions of train wrecks, and the types thereof. That way, they can rationally discuss which variety of train wreck they believe a series to be, and hopefully, keep the mayhem down to the level of swordplay and minor psychic powers.

Yeah, I know. Naive of me, isn’t it? Oh well, on with the show. Now I’m being hampered a bit here in that I’m not really that well-versed in some of the classic train wrecks to be had out there, especially since one of my goals has always been to read reviews and avoid the wrecks. Who knew I’d ever find myself lacking, thanks to that? Well, I’ll just have to do the best I can, but if you, dear reader, feel the urge to add a few examples (or even an entirely new type of train wreck) who am I to refuse to profit from your example?

So. And sa. (I wonder, was that the Nike logo in Japan? It seems appropriate.)

Kinds of train wreck:
Deus Ex Machina: The classical train-wreck ending, perfected by incompetent playwrights a couple of millenia before trains were invented. Everything is so screwed up and the writer is in such a corner, God himself (or a substitute thereof) must show up and fix things. Offenders: Crescent Love.

Splatterscreen: The writers can’t think of anything to finish the show properly, so they throw everything at the screen, whether it makes sense or not. Hopefully, something will stick, i.e.: it’s enough that something will appeal to someone. Offenders: Nuku-Nuku Dash!

Subversion: The writers spend 11 or 25 episodes building up to a grand climax, and then, at the last moment, reverse course against everything they’ve established in the series, leaving the audience betrayed. This type of ending tends to result in smashed TV sets. Grand Offender: Mahoromatic.

Incoherent: The ending is incomprehensible, either due to bad storytelling skills or something else forced an abortion. Offender: Evangelion.

Rush’em up: The series moves along at a sedate pace until someone realizes “OMG, we’ve only got two episodes to finish this in!” Then things start happening too quickly to keep up with, major plot points get dropped, or the narrative’s time frame gets compressed badly. Offender: Kanon.

Big Kaboom: A close relative to Splatterscreen, but more action-oriented. The writers don’t know how to end it, but figure if they make the final fight exciting enough, no one will notice that the end (or even the entire show) made no sense. Offender: Coyote Ragtime Show. Non-animé: Matrix triolgy.

Unresolved Ending: The show’s run may end, but nothing is resolved, or enough loose ends are left for a dozen sequels. Offenders: UFO Princess Valkyrie, Sister Princess, Martian Successor Nadesico. (Arguably, the latter was part of the parody and on purpose.)

Reset: A sub-type of the Non-ending; everything is put back the way it was so the series can be milked for further profit. Offender: Those Who Hunt Elves.

Neverending Story: It doesn’t end, it just goes on, and on, and on, and on…. Offenders: Inuyasha, Detective Conan, One Piece.

Endings aren’t always purely one or another. A sufficiently inept ending can manage to pull from two or three different types.

Given all that, what kind of train wreck are we in for with GSNK? My guess: a combination of Splatterscreen & Incoherent. We’ve finally remembered that Mayu is a succubus, and revealed most of Shungo’s repressed memory, but Mayu’s sudden illness (and connection to Shungo’s fainting spell) are terribly contrived, as is the obvious rendezvous set up for Ep. 12. But we’ve got Sexy Red-Eyed Reika and big kabooms galore in episode 11, so you know it’s going to be somewhat flashy…

I guess we’ll see this weekend, but I might be out of town. If so, I’ll comment later.

Oh, and my order from Robert’s is in. Woohoo!

Update: Will adds the following type:
Rocks Fall: Everybody dies. I can’t think of an anime offender at this point, but Aliens 3 is a good SF example.

Update: SDB suggests Blake’s 7 (British live-action SF series from a few years back) as an example of Rocks Fall. I never watched much of it, but I caught a few shows here and there. Definitely didnt like the last year, which seemed to run counter to what I thought was the theme of the show, making it also a Subversion.

This entry was posted in All Reviews, Art and Craft, Fansubs. Bookmark the permalink.

16 Responses to Goyshuso-sama Train Wreck?

  1. Owen S says:

    I see it as being more of like a Deus Ex Machina style ending, where everything’s wrapped up conveniently at the price of a completely destroyed suspension of disbelief (not like there was much to begin with, heh).

    The pacing in the last subbed episode, 11, was pretty decent, and I was starting to enjoy it after having resigned myself to using GSNK as an unwinding tool of some sort. Anything could happen, though, and I wouldn’t be surprised if the cast still has a few more aces up their sleeve, albeit campy and overused ones.

  2. Will says:

    Don’t forget the “rocks fall, everyone dies” variety of train wreck, but given your examples, it could be a sub-class of either Subversion, Incoherent, Big Kaboom, or in some cases all three.

    And the Japanese are big on Deus ex Corporation. Anime has taught me that there is nothing a massive family-owned business can not either buy or develop.

  3. Ubu Roi says:

    Yeah, #11 had it’s good points. Reika in a nightgown, rwowrrr. Oh yeah, I seem to recall some action too. And oddly, the question we’ve been asking since ep. 1 may be getting answered: Ryoko and Mikihiro know what happened between Mayu and Shungo way back when, and forcing them together is somehow supposed to fix it. What I’m wondering is: a) How many girls in this show aren’t succubi and b) Is Shungo’s power level supposed to be up around his sister’s, but whatever happened in the past has “crippled” him down to merely superhuman?

    True, that. Just ask Hanaukyo Taro.

    And good catch on the Rocks Fall ending.

  4. Wonderduck says:

    Fortunately, orbital lasers are only involved in the worst cases.

    Nuke ’em from orbit… it’s the only way to be sure.

    Rocks Fall: Everybody dies. I can’t think of an anime offender at this point, but Aliens 3 is a good SF example.

    Cowboy Bebop?

    Edit: I put your submission in spoiler tags.

  5. Ubu Roi says:

    I disagree with your example, because I don’t see it as a train wreck. I see it as the right ending… it hurt a lot, but it was the right ending, especially once Julia died. From the point that the crew started to split up, I had a very fatalistic feeling about the show; I felt that was where it was going to end up, and wondered if they’d chicken out and go for the happy ending. I’d have called that a train wreck. (Subversion.)

    The blues ain’t supposed to be happy.

  6. “Rocks Fall” is how Blakes Seven ended.

  7. Ubu Roi says:

    Based on the last year of the show, it was a mercy killing.

  8. Griffin says:

    The Dog Ate My Explanation: The entire show to date has centered around a big mystery or mysteries (which are treated as mysteries, with characters wondering what’s going on, etc., as opposed to premises of the show’s world). The show ends without decently explaining any of them. Offenders: Escaflowne. I wonder why Hitomi has all these mysterious powers? No, I mean it, I still wonder, because they established it as a big question but never answered it.

  9. Wonderduck says:

    Well, that’s why I put a questionmark after it. I’ve never see the series in question all the way through (though I have seen every episode at one time or another), so it’s a little disjointed in my head. It certainly seemed like a “rocks fall” scenario.

    How about Hamlet, does that work? Or if that’s too highbrow, Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead?

  10. The worst reset I’ve seen was the ending of “Happy Lesson”.

  11. Well, based on Aroduc’s writeup, it looks like the answer is “Splatterscreen”.

  12. Ubu Roi says:

    Yep. I called it. Splatterscreen. Not sure if the rest should be called Incoherent or Dog Ate My Explanation. (That one needs a shorter name. I’ll think about it while I”m out of town…)

    Update: At least it wasn’t Code Geass. That’s a whole series of splatterscreen goodness! What’s funny is reading comments about CG over at Animanachronism. Apparently, just about all the show’s fans share my assessment that it’s a complete and total wreck (incoherent), but fun to watch because of, rather than in spite of it. One of the reasons is, I think, the way it consistantly managed to hit all the tropes and clichés, yet still surprise the viewer. (I guess what I’m saying is really: “too bad it wasn’t as good as Code Geass.”)

    Needless to say, it’s going to appear in the Worst of 2007, next month. (Yes, I know it appeared in 2006 too.)

  13. Will says:

    Well having just finished GSNK Ep12, it was a trainwreck (but nothing nera as bad as it easily could have been).

    The Japanese love them some Disassociative Identity Disorder. Reika’s a pretty cliche case at that.

    The whole “I’ll kiss you then kiss her” scene made no sense because:
    1)Shungo showed no ill effects at all. if anything he seemed better off.
    2) They never established that succubi could return power they’d consumed, even to another succubus.

    And there is no chance Shinobu just forgives Hosaka after throwing her out of a moving helicopter. None.

  14. Will says:

    Well crud. Guess I mucked up the spoiler tag somehow.

  15. Ubu Roi says:

    No, I can’t get it to work either. Strange…..

    Edit. Helps if I don’t spell it “spoilier”

  16. Pingback: Mahou Meido Meganekko » Blog Archive » Manga: Rosario + Vampire

Leave a Reply